Before becoming the cult favourite it is today, Mr. Pibb was simply Coca-Cola’s answer to Dr. Pepper: a spiced cherry cola designed to compete in the growing flavoured soda category.

Since its initial launch in 1972, the formula has continued to evolve into what fans know today: a soda with a bolder cherry-forward profile and a stronger spice character. While Dr. Pepper is known for its mysterious blend of 23 flavours, Mr. Pibb takes a more direct approach: brighter cherry notes, more noticeable spice, and a slightly caramel-like cola base.

That difference has created one of soda’s most passionate rivalries. Some fans swear by Dr. Pepper, while others will tell you it’s Mr. Pibb all the way. But because it never received the same widespread availability in Canada, most people here never got the chance to pick a side.

Now you can finally settle the debate for yourself (and, of course, let us know whose side you’re on).

Available at Dank Mart, ships worldwide.